1939: La regle du jeu (Jean Renoir)
Here's a film that will probably forever be mentioned among the greats. It always seems to find its way to the top of those "best ever" lists, and I don't really ever see that changing.
It's a film that I greatly admire, I'm even in awe of it, but it's also the kind of film that makes me want to put together a "favorites" list. What I mean by this is that if all I ever saw were "the greats", films with as much universal support as this one, I'm not sure I'd have the same passion around film.
Many of my favorites are more flawed, less perfect, but they affect me more personally. When I first started being a cinephile, circa 1994, I wanted to like all the "best films", the ones the critics I respected loved the most. But then something happened. I found that I adamantly disagreed for the first time with Pauline Kael, one of the critics I most admired. It was probably either with Michael Mann's Thief or Michael Cimino's Year of the Dragon. Kael hated it, I loved it. And then I began to start questioning some of her other picks. Soon I decided that it was important to see "the greats", but it was even more important for me to determine my own set of classics, my own favorites, regardless of whether anyone else had championed them or not.
Tony Dayoub over at the excellent blog Cinema Viewfinder posted a similar discussion late last week. I thought Tony, as well as Sam Juliano (of another excellent blog Wonders in the Dark), made some fantastic points, and articulated this issue as well as anywhere I've ever seen.
All this to say I can't help but include La regle du jeu on this list. It doesn't affect me personally as much as some films from some of the other years or even some of the other Renoir films. But the direction is as graceful as anywhere I've ever seen and the performances are all magnificent. It's probably as perfect a film as any I can think of, but in my very humble opinion, perfect and favorite are not, and don't have to be, the same.
Other contenders for 1939: I probably have more gaps in this year than in any year so far. And some are downright embarrassing. The most notable films I still have to see are: Victor Fleming's Gone with the Wind (I'm embarrassed to say, but it's true!), Kenji Mizoguchi's The Story of the Late Chrysanthemums, and Howard Hawks' Only Angels Have Wings. Other films from this year I still need to see are: William Wyler's Wuthering Heights, John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln, George Stevens' Gunga Din, Zoltan Korda's The Four Feathers, Leo McCarey's Love Affair, Frank Capra's Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, John Ford's Drums Along the Mohawk, George Cukor's The Women, and Mitchell Leisen's Midnight. Of the films I have seen, there are three main runners-up. I find John Ford's Stagecoach to be one of the most entertaining westerns ever made. Raoul Walsh's The Roaring Twenties echoes many of the themes of another favorite of mine, Once Upon a Time in America, and is an absolutely fantastic crime film. Victor Fleming's The Wizard of Oz still affects me as one of the most beautiful and magical films the cinema has ever produced. Finally though I went with the Renoir as I admire it (maybe even love it) for it feels in some sense the most like real life -- complex, chaotic, and vital yet still harmonious and in some kind of balance.
Here's a film that will probably forever be mentioned among the greats. It always seems to find its way to the top of those "best ever" lists, and I don't really ever see that changing.
It's a film that I greatly admire, I'm even in awe of it, but it's also the kind of film that makes me want to put together a "favorites" list. What I mean by this is that if all I ever saw were "the greats", films with as much universal support as this one, I'm not sure I'd have the same passion around film.
Many of my favorites are more flawed, less perfect, but they affect me more personally. When I first started being a cinephile, circa 1994, I wanted to like all the "best films", the ones the critics I respected loved the most. But then something happened. I found that I adamantly disagreed for the first time with Pauline Kael, one of the critics I most admired. It was probably either with Michael Mann's Thief or Michael Cimino's Year of the Dragon. Kael hated it, I loved it. And then I began to start questioning some of her other picks. Soon I decided that it was important to see "the greats", but it was even more important for me to determine my own set of classics, my own favorites, regardless of whether anyone else had championed them or not.
Tony Dayoub over at the excellent blog Cinema Viewfinder posted a similar discussion late last week. I thought Tony, as well as Sam Juliano (of another excellent blog Wonders in the Dark), made some fantastic points, and articulated this issue as well as anywhere I've ever seen.
All this to say I can't help but include La regle du jeu on this list. It doesn't affect me personally as much as some films from some of the other years or even some of the other Renoir films. But the direction is as graceful as anywhere I've ever seen and the performances are all magnificent. It's probably as perfect a film as any I can think of, but in my very humble opinion, perfect and favorite are not, and don't have to be, the same.
Other contenders for 1939: I probably have more gaps in this year than in any year so far. And some are downright embarrassing. The most notable films I still have to see are: Victor Fleming's Gone with the Wind (I'm embarrassed to say, but it's true!), Kenji Mizoguchi's The Story of the Late Chrysanthemums, and Howard Hawks' Only Angels Have Wings. Other films from this year I still need to see are: William Wyler's Wuthering Heights, John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln, George Stevens' Gunga Din, Zoltan Korda's The Four Feathers, Leo McCarey's Love Affair, Frank Capra's Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, John Ford's Drums Along the Mohawk, George Cukor's The Women, and Mitchell Leisen's Midnight. Of the films I have seen, there are three main runners-up. I find John Ford's Stagecoach to be one of the most entertaining westerns ever made. Raoul Walsh's The Roaring Twenties echoes many of the themes of another favorite of mine, Once Upon a Time in America, and is an absolutely fantastic crime film. Victor Fleming's The Wizard of Oz still affects me as one of the most beautiful and magical films the cinema has ever produced. Finally though I went with the Renoir as I admire it (maybe even love it) for it feels in some sense the most like real life -- complex, chaotic, and vital yet still harmonious and in some kind of balance.
7/18/10 I watched Mitchell Leisen's Midnight. Charming enough, but I could never really connect with Don Ameche, and the story never involved me fully. I like Claudette Colbert a great deal, but this is not one of my favorite films with her.
7/25/10 I watched Leo McCarey's Love Affair. An extremely sad movie, full of some incredible moments but often a little unfocused. McCarey proves once again that he is fantastic with actors and can create fresh and real feeling about as well as anyone.
7/30/10 I watched Frank Capra's Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. It has a good deal of the hokeyness that Capra has become known for. But it also boasts some terrific moments with James Stewart and the most rich and unhinged performance I've ever seen from Claude Rains. A forced happy ending but an interesting watch with some food for thought.
8/4/10 I watched John Ford's Drums Along the Mohawk. Although it's a little long-winded at times for my taste, it reminds me of how important Ford was at retelling our country's history. Like Capra, he tries to remind us of our past, our values, and the events that led to the liberty that most of us are able to enjoy. Fonda was a strong heroic character and some of Ford's unusual visual abilities shine through.
8/9/10 I watched George Stevens' Gunga Din. Rollicking but a little long-winded at times for my taste. Seems to have been a major influence on Raiders of the Lost Ark and certainly has its share of memorable moments.
8/10/10 I watched John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln. Ford could be overly sentimental in moments. But Fonda's transition into Lincoln is eerily close. And the way that Ford stages and shoots the one murder in the film is among the most poetic and memorable things I've seen in his work. It rates up there with the titular murder in Valance. Also, some of Ford's static shots of Fonda thinking, particularly near the end, are powerful, deep, and affecting.
8/15/10 I watched Victor Fleming's Gone with the Wind. I'm very ashamed to admit it, but this is the first time that I've seen it. The characters are much more ambiguous than I imagined they would be, and Fleming doesn't really linger on anything. A little too long and its almost contempt for contemplation wore me out after awhile. But I'm very glad to have seen it.
8/16/10 I watched Howard Hawks' Only Angels Have Wings. Although it's more complex, thematically, emotionally, and formally, than His Girl Friday, I still prefer HGF. But this Hawks is definitely top-tier, featuring one of his very best scripts, and one of Grant's most sophisticated characters. All that is Hawksian is on display here, and it's a great ride, albeit slightly cold at times.
8/17/10 I watched George Cukor's The Women. The verbal mania really wore on me after awhile, and the gimmick of having no men ever on screen stopped working for me pretty soon into the film. Pretty good performances, and I'm sure it has value for certain people, but I never could really connect.
10/20/11 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Jamaica Inn. An uncharacteristic film from the master. It felt messy and under-budgeted. Pretty much a slog even with a strong Laughton performance.
10/5/13 I watched Mark Cousins' The Story of Film: An Odyssey: The 1930s The Great American Movie Genres and the Brilliance of European Film. Perhaps the least interesting installment to me so far, but I did really like those sections on Cocteau, Vigo, and Renoir.
9/13/15 I watched George Marshall and Edward F Cline's You Can't Cheat an Honest Man. While not as memorable as It's a Gift it is still an ample and powerful display of the unique comic approach of Fields. He was very different than anyone I have ever seen on screen but every bit as effective as Keaton or Chaplin or Tati.
2/10/18 I watched Ernst Lubitsch's Ninotchka. Far from Lubitsch's great works, although there are some wonderful moments like Ninotchka's reunion with her comrades back in Moscow.
1/15/21 I watched William Wyler's Wuthering Heights. Olivier is great and there are a few scenes where Toland's masterful talent is on display. But there is nearly wall-to-wall music and everything came off as more forced than felt.
