I put this as my third favorite when I recently did my "Favorites of My Favorites" post on Jean Renoir. It's yet another one of these gritty and very moody early works from Renoir. I also remember it having at its core one of the most wonderful stories of friendship I've ever seen (this time it's between Jean Gabin and Louis Jouvet). If there's anything I'm a sucker for on screen (maybe even more than a great love affair), it's a great friendship. We'll come back to this interest of mine, at least another couple of times, as we count down this list.
One thing I love so much about Renoir is the tone he's able to strike in these early films. He manages to be an extraordinary humanist without ever becoming overly sentimental. Not an easy balance to strike, and I think Renoir does it as well as anyone.
Akira Kurosawa re-made the film in 1957, and I haven't seen it yet. But this is one I can't wait to re-visit. It's also exciting for me to think about people, who have only seen The Rules of the Game and La grande illusion, discovering these early Renoir films for the first time. It's almost like going back in time and getting to watch your wise grandfather in his rough, and sometimes dangerous, early youth.
2/13/10 Another runner-up for me this year that I forgot to add would be Kenji Mizoguchi's Sisters of the Gion. I still have much to see by this great director. But this is one of my favorites of what I've seen so far.
6/20/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Secret Agent. It's staggering to see Hitch's modernism and genius already on display in such an early work. Peter Lorre in an incredibly entertaining role and some of the most psychologically disturbing scenes I've ever seen from Hitch, particularly the early murder in the mountains inter-cut with the disturbed dog. And Hitchcock is already doing so much with sound. This is very close to top-tier Hitch in my book.
7/1/10 I watched Gregory La Cava's My Man Godfrey. The zaniness of it all wasn't always up my alley. But there's a real original tone and sentiment here that makes this pretty damn original. Powell and Lombard have great chemistry, and there are some fantastic moments, including Lombard's impulsive engagement and shower scene.
7/1/10 I watched Frank Capra's Mr. Deeds Goes to Town. There's some real greatness here. But Capra can't always stay out of his way and his heavy-handed sentimentality. Regardless, this one boasts terrific performances from both Cooper and Arthur. And it's clear that Capra during this period was working at a very impressive level.
7/2/10 I watched Kenji Mizoguchi's Osaka Elegy. Although I don't think it's Mizoguchi at his absolute greatest, it's still a fantastic film. The composition of many of the shots is staggering and Mizoguchi creates a lasting impression with the character of Ayako. A great final minute or two and humanity, truth, and a very casual naturalism as Mizoguchi could do so well.
7/5/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Sabotage. It kinda dragged a little for me towards the end. But the celebrated set piece with the little boy and the bomb is rightly so, and Hitch's experimental touches and narrative mastery are already well on display. Minor Hitch but still well worth watching.
7/5/10 I watched John Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island. Although Ford's tremendous humanism is on display yet again, this one lacked a little depth and urgency for me. But as always, chez Ford, it is extremely well-acted and extremely well-told.
10/21/11 I watched Sacha Guitry's The Story of a Cheat. It's playful and in the first-person, and so I can see why it was meaningful to the filmmakers of the Nouvelle Vague. But now it's a little bit of a bore.
2/12/17 I rewatched George Stevens' Swing Time. Long time considered one of my favorite musicals since I first saw it in 1995, Astaire and Rogers still impress with their amazing chemistry and both their fast and elegantly slow numbers.
3/3/18 I watched Jack Conway's Libeled Lady. There are some fantastic scenes, certainly, including the scene when William Powell first has dinner with Myrna Loy and Walter Connolly and really every moment with Powell is top shelf. But some of the other scenes just seem to sag a little.
1/16/22 I rewatched Sacha Guitry's Le Roman d'un tricheur. There should be a name for a work of art that was significant in the development of another artist one greatly admires but for which the power is greatly diminished when consumed in a much different context and historical moment. I can see why Guitry's film would have such an influence on early Godard and Truffaut. It is liberated and playful in ways that no other film at that moment that I know of had been and it's told almost entirely in voiceover and first person.
2/13/22 I watched John Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island. The more John Ford I watch the more I feel that, as much as any American director of his generation, he explored the issue of race relations among blacks and whites in this country. Here, already in the 1930s, he gives us a story with black heroes and once again a scenario where our white lead needs his black friend in order to overcome the obstacles in front of him.
Has there ever been an American director who more consistently grappled with our country's past or who more often employed songs like "Taps" and "Dixie" that immediately call to mind our wars and our history?
Not to mention it is hard to overlook the deep humanism at work in this film, a quality of Ford I've read about but have only begun to appreciate.
