Monday, February 15, 2010

1939: La regle du jeu (Jean Renoir)

1939: La regle du jeu (Jean Renoir)

Here's a film that will probably forever be mentioned among the greats. It always seems to find its way to the top of those "best ever" lists, and I don't really ever see that changing.  


It's a film that I greatly admire, I'm even in awe of it, but it's also the kind of film that makes me want to put together a "favorites" list.  What I mean by this is that if all I ever saw were "the greats", films with as much universal support as this one, I'm not sure I'd have the same passion around film.  


Many of my favorites are more flawed, less perfect, but they affect me more personally.  When I first started being a cinephile, circa 1994, I wanted to like all the "best films", the ones the critics I respected loved the most.  But then something happened.  I found that I adamantly disagreed for the first time with Pauline Kael, one of the critics I most admired.  It was probably either with Michael Mann's Thief or Michael Cimino's Year of the Dragon.  Kael hated it, I loved it.  And then I began to start questioning some of her other picks.  Soon I decided that it was important to see "the greats", but it was even more important for me to determine my own set of classics, my own favorites, regardless of whether anyone else had championed them or not.  


Tony Dayoub over at the excellent blog Cinema Viewfinder posted a similar discussion late last week.  I thought Tony, as well as Sam Juliano (of another excellent blog Wonders in the Dark), made some fantastic points, and articulated this issue as well as anywhere I've ever seen.  


All this to say I can't help but include La regle du jeu on this list.  It doesn't affect me personally as much as some films from some of the other years or even some of the other Renoir films.  But the direction is as graceful as anywhere I've ever seen and the performances are all magnificent.  It's probably as perfect a film as any I can think of, but in my very humble opinion, perfect and favorite are not, and don't have to be, the same.

Other contenders for 1939: I probably have more gaps in this year than in any year so far.  And some are downright embarrassing.  The most notable films I still have to see are:  Victor Fleming's Gone with the Wind (I'm embarrassed to say, but it's true!), Kenji Mizoguchi's The Story of the Late Chrysanthemums, and Howard Hawks' Only Angels Have Wings.   Other films from this year I still need to see are: William Wyler's Wuthering Heights, John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln, George Stevens' Gunga Din, Zoltan Korda's The Four Feathers, Leo McCarey's Love Affair, Frank Capra's Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, John Ford's Drums Along the Mohawk, George Cukor's The Women, and Mitchell Leisen's Midnight.  Of the films I have seen, there are three main runners-up.  I find John Ford's Stagecoach to be one of the most entertaining westerns ever made.  Raoul Walsh's The Roaring Twenties echoes many of the themes of another favorite of mine, Once Upon a Time in America, and is an absolutely fantastic crime film. Victor Fleming's The Wizard of Oz still affects me as one of the most beautiful and magical films the cinema has ever produced.  Finally though I went with the Renoir as I admire it (maybe even love it) for it feels in some sense the most like real life -- complex, chaotic, and vital yet still harmonious and in some kind of balance. 

7/18/10 I watched Mitchell Leisen's Midnight.  Charming enough, but I could never really connect with Don Ameche, and the story never involved me fully.  I like Claudette Colbert a great deal, but this is not one of my favorite films with her.  

7/25/10 I watched Leo McCarey's Love Affair.  An extremely sad movie, full of some incredible moments but often a little unfocused.  McCarey proves once again that he is fantastic with actors and can create fresh and real feeling about as well as anyone.  

7/30/10 I watched Frank Capra's Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.  It has a good deal of the hokeyness that Capra has become known for. But it also boasts some terrific moments with James Stewart and the most rich and unhinged performance I've ever seen from Claude Rains. A forced happy ending but an interesting watch with some food for thought.   

8/4/10 I watched John Ford's Drums Along the Mohawk.  Although it's a little long-winded at times for my taste, it reminds me of how important Ford was at retelling our country's history.  Like Capra, he tries to remind us of our past, our values, and the events that led to the liberty that most of us are able to enjoy.  Fonda was a strong heroic character and some of Ford's unusual visual abilities shine through.  

8/9/10 I watched George Stevens' Gunga Din.  Rollicking but a little long-winded at times for my taste.  Seems to have been a major influence on Raiders of the Lost Ark and certainly has its share of memorable moments.  

8/10/10 I watched John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln.  Ford could be overly sentimental in moments.  But Fonda's transition into Lincoln is eerily close.  And the way that Ford stages and shoots the one murder in the film is among the most poetic and memorable things I've seen in his work.  It rates up there with the titular murder in Valance.  Also, some of Ford's static shots of Fonda thinking, particularly near the end, are powerful, deep, and affecting.

8/15/10 I watched Victor Fleming's Gone with the Wind.  I'm very ashamed to admit it, but this is the first time that I've seen it.  The characters are much more ambiguous than I imagined they would be, and Fleming doesn't really linger on anything.  A little too long and its almost contempt for contemplation wore me out after awhile.  But I'm very glad to have seen it.  

8/16/10 I watched Howard Hawks' Only Angels Have Wings. Although it's more complex, thematically, emotionally, and formally, than His Girl Friday, I still prefer HGF.  But this Hawks is definitely top-tier, featuring one of his very best scripts, and one of Grant's most sophisticated characters.  All that is Hawksian is on display here, and it's a great ride, albeit slightly cold at times.  

8/17/10 I watched George Cukor's The Women.  The verbal mania really wore on me after awhile, and the gimmick of having no men ever on screen stopped working for me pretty soon into the film.  Pretty good performances, and I'm sure it has value for certain people, but I never could really connect.  

10/20/11 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Jamaica Inn.  An uncharacteristic film from the master.  It felt messy and under-budgeted.  Pretty much a slog even with a strong Laughton performance.  

10/5/13 I watched Mark Cousins' The Story of Film: An Odyssey:  The 1930s The Great American Movie Genres and the Brilliance of European Film.  Perhaps the least interesting installment to me so far, but I did really like those sections on Cocteau, Vigo, and Renoir.  

9/13/15 I watched George Marshall and Edward F Cline's You Can't Cheat an Honest Man.  While not as memorable as It's a Gift it is still an ample and powerful display of the unique comic approach of Fields.  He was very different than anyone I have ever seen on screen but every bit as effective as Keaton or Chaplin or Tati.

2/10/18 I watched Ernst Lubitsch's Ninotchka.  Far from Lubitsch's great works, although there are some wonderful moments like Ninotchka's reunion with her comrades back in Moscow.

1/15/21 I watched William Wyler's Wuthering Heights.  Olivier is great and there are a few scenes where Toland's masterful talent is on display.  But there is nearly wall-to-wall music and everything came off as more forced than felt.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

1938: Holiday (George Cukor)








1938: Holiday (George Cukor)
Ah, how Cukor pulls this one off for me!  There's as much suspense in this romantic comedy as there is in any mystery or drama I can think of from this period.  I don't want to ruin it for those who haven't seen it. But suffice it to say, you're not sure where Cukor's taking the story until almost the very last second.


I guess I also have a thing about conformity.  The way that this film deals with familial pressure and the pressure to conform affects me in a very personal way.  In fact, it affects me as deeply as any film from the thirties.  


This is one of those years where it's absolutely no contest for me. Holiday is a desert island film for me.  Brilliant, I think, but more important, just a film that's extremely personal for me.  



Other contenders for 1938: There are a few films I still need to see from this year, most notably Michael Curtiz's Angels with Dirty Faces, Sergei Eisenstein's Alexander Nevsky, and Alfred Hitchcock's The Lady Vanishes.  I do really like Howard Hawks' Bringing Up Baby but not near as much as the Cukor.  And, I love Jean Renoir's La bete humaine. But I can't say it affects me in the same deeply personal way as Holiday.


7/13/10 I watched Michael Curtiz's Angels with Dirty Faces.  There are some tremendous moments, particularly when Cagney starts yelping near the end and the shootout in the drugstore.  But there's something about Curtiz's touch for me that often feels a little heavy.  All in all, I enjoyed it even if it didn't all totally work for me.  


7/15/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's The Lady Vanishes.  It's one of his most well-respected British films, but I must say I was a little disappointed in it.  I enjoyed much of the humor of the first thirty minutes, but I wasn't as involved once the suspense part of the film kicked in.  Based on one viewing of The Lady Vanishes, I still much prefer The 39 Steps and consider it by far my favorite of what I've seen from Hitch's British period.  


7/25/10 I watched Sergei Eisenstein's Alexander Nevsky.  Devoid of Eisensteinian montage, this one derives its power from a certain spareness and a commitment to combat verisimilitude.  I could never fully connect to the characters, but Prokofiev provides a haunting score and some of the acting is quite strong.  

Saturday, February 13, 2010

1937: You Only Live Once (Fritz Lang)

1937: You Only Live Once (Fritz Lang)

I know exactly where I saw this one for the first time.  It was the exact same theater where I first saw The Blue Angel.   That one located on Rue Mouffetard.

Why don't we ever hear the term "homme fatale"?  Surely there 's a whole group of films where the term would apply -- where it's the man that's destructive, that brings the woman down, rather than the other way around.  I mean I can think of at least a few of these films: Scarface (either version), White Heat, Bonnie and Clyde, and this early Lang noir, You Only Live Once.  

Way I see it is this, in order for a noir with a femme fatale to reach its full potential, you have to have a somewhat naive and innocent male counterpart.  Same goes for noir with an homme fatale.  If that's true, I can't think of anyone better to play the part than Sylvia Sidney.  She had those eyes for days and a face that always seemed a frame away from breaking into tears.  

It's downright painful, right, watching MacMurray in Double Indemnity and Mitchum in Out of the Past as their respective women bring 'em down.  That's how I feel watching this early Lang, too.  I can almost hear myself now, "Damn it Fonda, stop it already, can't you see what you're doing to her?  Don't you know how she's going to end up?" 

I'm fully along for the ride on this one.  It's one of my favorite noirs.   

Other contenders for 1937: I have gaps here, too.  These include notably:  Sadao Yamanaka's Humanity and Paper Balloons, Leo McCarey's Make Way for Tomorrow and The Awful Truth, Mitchell Leisen's Easy Living, Alfred Hitchcock's Young and Innocent, William Wellman's A Star Is Born (I love Cukor's version.  I need to see this!), and Frank Capra's Lost Horizon.  I only have two real contenders for runner-up at this point.  Garbo's performance in George Cukor's Camille absolutely devastates me.  And, of course, I'm a huge fan of Jean Renoir's La grande illusion.  Finally though, in a very close decision between Lang and Renoir, I probably chose the Lang because it's a little less perfect, a little less classic, and in situations like this, I feel I have to give the tie to the underdog.  

7/10/10 I watched Mitchell Leisen's Easy Living.  Let me preface any other comments by saying that screwball comedy is probably my least favorite of all genres.   It just wears on me after a short while.  But there are fine moments in here and overall I would rate it as pretty enjoyable. Even though Preston Sturges penned the script, it really doesn't ever reach the heights of his best work.  

7/11/10 I watched Leo McCarey's Make Way for Tomorrow.  One of the best depictions of aging I have ever seen in film and full of many gut-wrenching and poignant moments.  I didn't fully connect with the character of the aging woman.  But otherwise, I found it to be an utterly bold, unique, and powerful work.  

7/14/10 I watched Leo McCarey's The Awful Truth.  I had seen this one about 15 years ago in a Parisian theater and had a mediocre reaction to it but man was I wrong.  This has some of the greatest moments and exchanges of this entire period, particularly the final scene and almost every scene with Mr. Smith, the dog.  I still may slightly prefer His Girl Friday, but this is undeniably a great work.  

7/15/10 I watched David Hand's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. Animation has never really been my thing so I'm not the best judge here.  But all in all, it was entertaining, charming, with a couple of very memorable songs.  

7/22/10 I watched Frank Capra's Lost Horizon.  A movie full of ideas and quite brave for its time.  I've never read the original novel, but I certainly felt this to be both the most aesthetically and intellectually daring movie I've seen from Capra.  One to certainly revisit as it feels positively dense and fresh.  

7/25/10 I watched William Wellman's A Star Is Born.  It is at once an extremely tender and tragic love story.  Cukor's version is one of my favorite films of all time, but Wellman's original certainly doesn't disappoint.  It's a wonderfully felt film, full of unforgettable moments and sincere connections.  Highly recommended.

7/29/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Young and Innocent.  Probably the least involving film I've seen from the master.  He proves to be adept at giving you the inner psychology of his characters, but otherwise everything feels thin and uninspired.  

4/21/12 I watched Gregory La Cava's Stage Door.  Although at times a little consistent, a very moving tale about the world of theater.  Typically strong performances from Rogers and Hepburn, but the real standout is the subplot of Kay and the heartwrenching performance of Andrea Leeds.  

8/25/12 I watched Michael Powell's The Edge of the World.  Perhaps the greatest of all films are those haunted by either life or death.  In this case, there's a cloud hovering over every moment that suggests the latter but a vitality in every frame that leans more towards the former.  Either way, this earthy, hefty work is among Powell's very best.

12/29/12 I watched King Vidor's Stella Dallas.  I'll admit I'm a sucker for these types of weepies and this one was no exception.  It doesn't hurt that Vidor was a real master and unafraid to linger in some very dark, uncomfortable places like the scene in the soda shop.  Melodrama like we really don't see anymore and one of the better of its kind.

2/26/17 I watched Sadao Yamanaka's Humanity and Paper Balloons.  I know nothing at all about the filmmaker and it was the first of his films I have seen.  What impressed most was the film's study of class and the way it examines the idea that there are other things in life of far greater value than money.  Yamanaka also infuses the film with a similar strain of poetry that seems to exist in the other great works of Japanese cinema.  

12/25/20 I watched Ernst Lubitsch's Angel.  Lubitsch's sophisticated touch is on full display in almost every second of the final thirty minutes.  It is a sophistication that is sexy, leaving the viewer on edge unsure how the characters will work out the knots that their lives have become.  Although it is the only time Lubitsch worked with Dietrich, he taps into her elusiveness, her allure, her power.  And I can't recall Herbert Marshall ever being in fuller command of the screen.  

Friday, February 12, 2010

1936: Les bas-fonds (Jean Renoir)

1936: Les bas-fonds (Jean Renoir)

I put this as my third favorite when I recently did my "Favorites of My Favorites" post on Jean Renoir.  It's yet another one of these gritty and very moody early works from Renoir.  I also remember it having at its core one of the most wonderful stories of friendship I've ever seen (this time it's between Jean Gabin and Louis Jouvet).  If there's anything I'm a sucker for on screen (maybe even more than a great love affair), it's a great friendship.  We'll come back to this interest of mine, at least another couple of times, as we count down this list.  


One thing I love so much about Renoir is the tone he's able to strike in these early films.  He manages to be an extraordinary humanist without ever becoming overly sentimental.  Not an easy balance to strike, and I think Renoir does it as well as anyone.  

Akira Kurosawa re-made the film in 1957, and I haven't seen it yet.  But this is one I can't wait to re-visit.  It's also exciting for me to think about people, who have only seen The Rules of the Game and La grande illusion, discovering these early Renoir films for the first time.  It's almost like going back in time and getting to watch your wise grandfather in his rough, and sometimes dangerous, early youth.

Other contenders for 1936: As with previous years, I have some things from this year I still need to see.  These include Howard Hawks' The Road to Glory, Sacha Guitry's The Story of a Cheat, James Whale's Show Boat, John Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island, Alfred Hitchcock's Secret Agent and Sabotage, Gregory La Cava's My Man Godfrey, Douglas Sirk's Schlusakkord, Frank Capra's Mr. Deeds Goes to Town, and Kenji Mizoguchi's Osaka Elegy.  I also need to re-watch Modern Times at some point.  I think I've only seen it once, and for some reason, it didn't have the impact on me of City Lights, or even The Kid.  I would have two fairly close runner-ups.  George Stevens' Swing Time might be my second favorite musical.  And Jean Renoir's 40 minute Partie de campagne (A Day in the Country) is my favorite short film of all time, and probably the most poetic film Renoir ever made.  

2/13/10 Another runner-up for me this year that I forgot to add would be Kenji Mizoguchi's Sisters of the Gion.  I still have much to see by this great director.  But this is one of my favorites of what I've seen so far.  

6/20/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Secret Agent.  It's staggering to see Hitch's modernism and genius already on display in such an early work.  Peter Lorre in an incredibly entertaining role and some of the most psychologically disturbing scenes I've ever seen from Hitch, particularly the early murder in the mountains inter-cut with the disturbed dog.  And Hitchcock is already doing so much with sound. This is very close to top-tier Hitch in my book.  

7/1/10 I watched Gregory La Cava's My Man Godfrey.  The zaniness of it all wasn't always up my alley.  But there's a real original tone and sentiment here that makes this pretty damn original.  Powell and Lombard have great chemistry, and there are some fantastic moments, including Lombard's impulsive engagement and shower scene. 

7/1/10 I watched Frank Capra's Mr. Deeds Goes to Town.  There's some real greatness here.  But Capra can't always stay out of his way and his heavy-handed sentimentality.  Regardless, this one boasts terrific performances from both Cooper and Arthur.  And it's clear that Capra during this period was working at a very impressive level.  

7/2/10 I watched Kenji Mizoguchi's Osaka Elegy.  Although I don't think it's Mizoguchi at his absolute greatest, it's still a fantastic film. The composition of many of the shots is staggering and Mizoguchi creates a lasting impression with the character of Ayako.  A great final minute or two and humanity, truth, and a very casual naturalism as Mizoguchi could do so well.  

7/5/10 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's Sabotage.  It kinda dragged a little for me towards the end.   But the celebrated set piece with the little boy and the bomb is rightly so, and Hitch's experimental touches and narrative mastery are already well on display.  Minor Hitch but still well worth watching.  

7/5/10 I watched John Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island.  Although Ford's tremendous humanism is on display yet again, this one lacked a little depth and urgency for me.  But as always, chez Ford, it is extremely well-acted and extremely well-told.  

10/21/11 I watched Sacha Guitry's The Story of a Cheat.  It's playful and in the first-person, and so I can see why it was meaningful to the filmmakers of the Nouvelle Vague.  But now it's a little bit of a bore.  

2/12/17 I rewatched George Stevens' Swing Time.  Long time considered one of my favorite musicals since I first saw it in 1995, Astaire and Rogers still impress with their amazing chemistry and both their fast and elegantly slow numbers.  

3/3/18 I watched Jack Conway's Libeled Lady.  There are some fantastic scenes, certainly, including the scene when William Powell first has dinner with Myrna Loy and Walter Connolly and really every moment with Powell is top shelf.  But some of the other scenes just seem to sag a little.  

1/16/22 I rewatched Sacha Guitry's Le Roman d'un tricheur.  There should be a name for a work of art that was significant in the development of another artist one greatly admires but for which the power is greatly diminished when consumed in a much different context and historical moment.  I can see why Guitry's film would have such an influence on early Godard and Truffaut.  It is liberated and playful in ways that no other film at that moment that I know of had been and it's told almost entirely in voiceover and first person.  

2/13/22 I watched John Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island.  The more John Ford I watch the more I feel that, as much as any American director of his generation, he explored the issue of race relations among blacks and whites in this country.  Here, already in the 1930s, he gives us a story with black heroes and once again a scenario where our white lead needs his black friend in order to overcome the obstacles in front of him.  

Has there ever been an American director who more consistently grappled with our country's past or who more often employed songs like "Taps" and "Dixie" that immediately call to mind our wars and our history?

Not to mention it is hard to overlook the deep humanism at work in this film, a quality of Ford I've read about but have only begun to appreciate.

Thursday, February 11, 2010

1935: The 39 Steps (Alfred Hitchcock)

1935: The 39 Steps (Alfred Hitchcock)

This next pick probably illustrates, as much as any year, my distinction on this list of "favorites" versus "best".  I personally like the distinction, as some of the "best films" haven't always moved me, and some of my favorite films aren't necessarily considered the best.  This Hitchcock is considered by no one I've ever read as his best.  And, I'll admit that it's not near as depthful and artful as some of his later work.  However, it is, along with Rear Window, Suspicion, Shadow of a Doubt, and Marnie, one of my favorites by the director.  

Hitchcock has always had a playful streak, and it's in full bloom here. The 39 Steps is sexy, full of twists and turns, and just a purely fun romp. I'll admit, I usually need my mind engaged to fully embrace a film.  But, for some reason, I find this one so well-directed, the story so well-told, that I'm satisfied shutting off my brain and just letting one of the masters entertain me.  









Other contenders for 1935: As with other years, there are still some things I need to see.  These include: Leo McCarey's Ruggles of Red Gap, James Whale's Bride of Frankenstein, George Cukor's Sylvia Scarlett, Howard Hawks' Ceiling Zero, Mikio Naruse's Wife! Be Like a Rose, John Ford's The Informer, Michael Curtiz's Captain Blood, and Richard Boleslawski's Les Miserables.  There are two films I have seen that are strong runner-ups for my top pick.  Jean Renoir's Le crime de Monsieur Lange is another one of my very favorite by the director.  And, Mark Sandrich's Top Hat may very well be my favorite musical of all time.  I finally though gave the spot to the Hitchcock as I think it's one of the most fun and purely entertaining films of this entire era.  


5/1/10 I watched James Whale's Bride of Frankenstein.  I know that I'm in the minority on this one, but I definitely much preferred Whale's original Frankenstein film.  I found the original's direction to be more powerful and overall there seemed to be a little more heart in the first film.  But, the scene between Frankenstein and the blind man is a classic and fully felt.  

6/6/10 I watched Howard Hawks' Ceiling Zero. A tremendous performance by Cagney and one of the most incredible scenes of sustained tension I have ever seen as Texas navigates the skies.  Tough to find but so glad I finally got to see it.  Absolutely top tier Hawks. 


6/10/10 I watched Richard Boleslawski's Les Miserables.  Though probably the type of film the Turks of the New Wave would have rejected, as it does perhaps lack a little personality, it is extremely well-made.  March and Laughton are fantastic, and it doesn't hurt that they have the great Gregg Toland along for the ride.


6/21/10 I watched John Ford's The Informer.  The older I get, the more I realize how much depth the "masters" were able to achieve in some of their work.  I saw it recently when I watched Yasujiro Ozu's I Was Born, But..., and it certainly is evident in Ford's thematic treatment of Jippo's betrayal of Frankie.  Ford is able to achieve such universality with such simplicity.  And there's a sophistication to his concerns and characters that elevates him among most of his peers.  


6/25/10 I watched Michael Curtiz's Captain Blood.  I can't say I'm a natural fan of the swashbuckler genre or of Curtiz's campy style (I struggled even a little with his version of Robin Hood.)  But the charm and appeal of Flynn is hard to resist here, and he makes a very convincing hero.  Enjoyable although at times hard to take it for any more than that.  


7/9/10 I watched George Cukor's Sylvia Scarlett.  It's a real offbeat film for the time and didn't always hold together for me.  But when it's great, in the first few scenes between Hepburn and the painter, and the deliberation between the two on the train near the end, it's downright classic.  An awesome location, in the painter's home, and a few very fine Hepburn moments.  


3/1/12 I watched Henry Hathaway's Peter Ibbetson.  An unusually esoteric film that starts out normal enough but devolves into something far more elusive.  I'm not sure exactly what Hathaway is up to - it is unique but so strange as to lose interest for me by a certain point.

8/5/13 I watched Leo McCarey's Ruggles of Red Gap.  The Hollywood happy ending has become an almost absolute, an artificial emotional high that a filmmaker must provide the audience before turning the lights back on.  It is troubling and says as much about the American psyche as McDonald's or Hummers.  But what if there was a time when it is was not obligatory, when instead it was the optimal way to bring a story to a close.  I have seen my fair share of movies, and most of my favorites tend to eschew the happy ending for something else altogether.  Rarely, if ever, have I seen a movie like Ruggles, that without its happy ending, would simply lose everything, its reason for being, its internal logic, and its deeply lasting effect.  Of all I have seen, I put this one up as the quintessential happy ending.  If Hollywood were only taking its lessons from Ruggles, we may still be at the center of the most important and profound artistic medium of the last 150 years.   

9/22/13 I watched Mark Cousins' The Story of Film: An Odyssey:  1918-1935:  The Great Rebel Filmmakers Around the World.  Highlights for me included the parts on Gance, Ozu, and China's cinema at this time that is entirely unknown to me.  I look forward to seeing La Roue, The Goddess, and The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.  

1/11/17 I rewatched Mark Sandrich's Top Hat.  I think I haven't seen it since I saw it for the first time in '94-'95 and it quickly became my favorite musical.  It is a little more corny than I remember and a little more loose but Astaire's elegance and grace are a sight to behold and the music (courtesy of Berlin and Steiner) is catchy and moving.

7/24/18 I watched George Cukor's David Copperfield.  Some of the moments with young David rank as some of the greatest ever put on screen by a child actor.  But the film just feels a bit jumbled, as though Cukor didn't have the funds or focus to capture things the way he would have liked.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

1934: L'atalante (Jean Vigo)

1934: L'atalante (Jean Vigo)

I first saw this at one of my favorite theaters in the world, Cafe des Images in Herouville-Saint-Clair, just outside Caen, France.  When it was over, I knew I'd seen something very special.  Vigo died when he was only 29 -years-old but forever left his mark on the medium -- this film ranks up there for me as one of the two or three most poetic films in the history of cinema.  
I think it's fairly easy to create a poetic moment in a film.  Usually, you just have to use slow-motion and some evocative music, and presto, you've probably created a moment of poetry.  But, sustaining this lyricism and poetry for the entire duration of a narrative film is nearly impossible.  For me, the only other films I can think of that accomplish this are Tabu: A Story of the South Seas, some Tarkovsky, The Thin Red Line, The Night of the Hunter, and maybe McCabe & Mrs. Miller.


Without Vigo, I'm not sure we'd have two of my other favorite filmmakers: Leos Carax and Jim Jarmusch (I'm not positive about Carax, but I've read where Jarmusch has cited this film as a major influence.)  Vigo was a master of mood, atmosphere, and creating lasting images.  There's nothing else quite like this film, and it's one I'll continue to re-visit with great enthusiasm as the years pass.

Other contenders for 1934: I'm not without my gaps in this year, as well.  I still need to see Yasujiro Ozu's A Story of Floating Weeds, Ernst Lubitsch's The Merry Widow, Alfred Hitchcock's first The Man Who Knew Too Much, Josef von Sternberg's The Scarlet Empress, Raymond Bernard's Les Miserables, Edgar Ulmer's The Black Cat, and Jack Conway, Howard Hawks, and William Wellman's Viva Villa!  I need and plan to re-watch Howard Hawks' Twentieth Century.  For some reason, the first time it didn't have much of an impact.  But there are three other films from this year that did challenge for the top spot. I'm a big fan of the interplay between Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert in Frank Capra's It Happened One Night.  I think Gable's cynicism probably helps offset some of Capra's sentimental tendencies that sometimes rub me the wrong way.  I haven't seen that much of WC Fields, but Norman McLeod's It's a Gift had me laughing as hard as anything I've seen from this period.   And Jean Renoir's Toni is my second favorite film from the director.  But, finally it's L'atalante, with its one of a kind beauty and lyricism, that has the most special place for me this year.

5/30/10 I watched Edgar G Ulmer's The Black Cat.  Features my favorite performance so far from Boris Karloff.  He is just deliciously sinister in it, and it's obvious he's having great fun with the role.  And the film also makes a case for Ulmer being incredibly inventive and having a superb eye.  

6/11/10 I watched Josef von Sternberg's The Scarlet Empress.  An epic with a ton of personality and a film with a tremendous reputation. Emotionally, I struggled with it and never fully connected.  But Dietrich is wonderful and von Sternberg pulls out all the stops.  

6/16/10 I watched Raymond Bernard's Les Miserables.  They certainly cut no corners with this 280 minute version of the Hugo novel.  I like some of the characterization we gain in this longer version, when compared to the Richard Boleslawski film of the following year.  But all in all, I felt closer to the characters in the Boleslawski film than in this one.  


6/23/10 I watched Howard Hawks' Twentieth Century.  I had seen it before but couldn't remember it very well.  It's amazing seeing it now to realize how much of a sibling film it is to His Girl Friday.  Both revolve around the male protagonist trying to lure the female lead back into his world through cunning, manipulation, and humor.  Although I prefer Friday (it's one of my all-time favorites), John Barrymore is absolutely incredible here and single-handedly makes it a great film in my book.

7/10/10 I watched Yasujiro Ozu's A Story of Floating Weeds.  It didn't affect me emotionally on the same level as another one of his films I saw recently, I Was Born, But....  However, it still demonstrates Ozu's mastery.  His eye, his feeling for nature, the framing, the cinematography are all otherworldly.  And here, in the final shots, Ozu says so much by saying nothing.   Ozu was still doing silent work when most had moved onto sound.  And his silent films have a poetry about them that is very singular and memorable.  

6/26/11 I watched Alfred Hitchcock's The Man Who Knew Too Much. Some nice, early Hitch touches, and of course Lorre is great.  But some of the plotting feels a little suspect, and doesn't pack the same punch as the remake.  

2/19/17 I watched John Ford's The Lost Patrol.  What I was most struck by, aside from Ford's signature ability to bring out the haunting poetry in natural landscapes, is a certain modern quality to the work.  McLaglen's physicality towards the end does not feel too much different than Pacino in the latter stages of Scarface and the fact that Ford almost never cuts to the opposition gives the film artful restraint that really helps create the effective, ominous atmosphere he sustains throughout.

5/28/18 I rewatched Frank Capra's It Happened One Night.  This film is a marvel.  I loved it the first couple of times I saw it and continue to be astounded by every aspect of it.

1/5/19 I watched Mervyn LeRoy's Heat Lightning.  A noir that stands out the most because it never quite allows you to know what it is or where it is going.  Everything about it just seems a little off, from the gas station location to the actors' faces to the way the camera moves.  I am not sure if it would be considered pre-code but it has a sense of being on the edge and pushing Code boundaries like the other great pre-code cinema I have seen to date.

10/14/19 I watched Ernst Lubitsch's The Merry Widow.  A few great moments like the encounter at Maxim's between Chevalier and Jeanette MacDonald but it lacks the overall shape and passion of the greater works by the master filmmaker.
12/27/21 I watched King Vidor's Our Daily Bread.  From a political perspective it was probably an important film, almost propaganda to the American people struggling through The Great Depression.  Visually, it is quite striking as well as is usually the case with Vidor's cinema.
1/9/23 I watched John Ford's Judge Priest.  It's nice to see Ford take on our history, and particularly nice that he's engaged with one of arguably our most shameful moments, our Civil War.  And it's great to see Will Rogers and the strong presence he brought to the screen.  What's less comfortable is what Ford is saying, is he celebrating the Confederacy, challenging our nation's early morals and actions?  

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

1933: Das Testament des Dr. Mabuse (Fritz Lang)

1933: Das Testament des Dr. Mabuse (Fritz Lang)

I'll start by saying that of all my top picks, this is absolutely one of the most tenuous.  I like this Lang film, but there are probably another seven or eight by him that I like even better (The Big Heat, Metropolis, M, Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, Moonfleet, The Woman in the Window, You Only Live Once, and Destiny).  And I still have some Lang films to see.

My pick has a lot to do with 1933 being a slightly less stellar year, and admittedly I still have some major gaps to fill.

I first saw Mabuse at a great place that used to be in Paris called the "Videotheque de Paris".  It was a film library that also had one fantastic theater.  I'm not sure why it closed, but I had several very memorable nights there.  I saw Claire Denis present a screening of her film J'ai pas sommeil, and it was there that I saw a favorite of mine, Rossellini's Germany Year Zero, for the first time.  


Anyway, as I remember it, the thing that most impressed me with this film was Lang's extraordinary inventiveness.  I remember watching it and being in awe of all that he was doing for such an early film.  It has a fairly complex narrative for a film of this era and just felt formally years ahead of other films I had seen from this period.  I believe I've only seen it once so it is a bit vague in my memory.  But I remember it having a terrific finale, as well, if I'm not mistaken.

Other contenders for 1933:  My  inspiration for doing these posts, Dave Hicks, has a film at the top of his list for this year that I've never seen.  That film, The Bitter Tea of General Yen, is something I want to see as soon as possible.  Other films I still need to see from this year are:  Howard Hawks' Today We Live, Merian Cooper and Ernest Schoedsack's King Kong (embarrassed but I've never seen it in its entirety), Alfred Green's Baby Face, Mervyn LeRoy's Gold Diggers of 1933, and Frank Borzage's A Man's Castle.  Of the films I've seen from this year, I remember Max Ophuls' Liebelei having some of the greatest woods and snow cinematography in the history of film.  And, I love Duck Soup.  It's one of the funniest films I've ever seen.  I ultimately though decided to give the edge to the Lang film for its sheer formal innovation.


5/15/10 I watched Merian Cooper and Ernest Schoedsack's King Kong. There are some tremendous moments, particularly the unveiling of Kong at the New York theater.  But some of the action scenes in the jungle went on too long for me and didn't really maximize the suspense. An incredibly impressive accomplishment though for its time.


5/24/10 I watched Mervyn LeRoy's Gold Diggers of 1933.  Some of the dance sequences are absolutely mind-blowing.  But much of the story in between felt a little heavy-handed to me and didn't move me as much as I would like.  Busby Berkeley's work though is really something to see.  


9/13/10 I watched Howard Hawks' Air Force.  Hawks definitely demonstrates a love and knowledge for the material, but I find this to be one of his more overlong pieces.  Some wonderful moments, and an extraordinary performance from Harry Carey, but still a little underwhelming, relative to some of his better work.


2/25/12 I watched Ernst Lubitsch's Design for Living.  One of the very strongest of all the Lubitsch films that I've seen and probably the clearest display of the famous "Lubitsch touch".  Lubitsch had this ability to go from mania to pathos almost within the same shot.  Bold, sexy, and probably a major influence on Jules and Jim, as well as the entire French New Wave.


2/26/12 I watched Lloyd Bacon's 42nd Street.  A loose, free-form musical with loads of energy and insight into the behind-the-scenes world of theater.  Most memorable for its passion.  The grace and personality of the best Astaire pics though resonate more with me.  

5/19/12 I watched Rouben Mamoulian's Queen Christina.  A strong Garbo performance although I'm partial to her work in The Mysterious Lady and Camille.  The final shot though makes it all worthwhile.

9/3/12 I watched Archie Mayo's The Mayor of Hell.  Some strong performances, particularly from a few of the kids, but screwy and often feels like it's throwing its plot implausibilities quickly into the closet before anyone notices.  Mostly forgettable for me.  

9/22/12 I watched Alfred E Green's Baby Face.  A little too neat for me most of the time, but features yet another excellent Stanwyck performance and is interesting as a pre-code artifact.  

9/23/12 I watched William Wellman's Wild Boys of the Road.  It has heart, I'll give it that, but I'm not sure the acting always pulls it through, and it ends up feeling more well-intentioned than affecting.

9/30/12 I watched A Edward Sutherland's International House.  A sort of messy, slapstick pre-code trifle that gains great import those few times when WC Fields hits the screen.  

10/27/12 I watched Lloyd Bacon's Picture Snatcher.  Interesting for yet another great Cagney performance and a surprisingly violent shoot-out near the end.  Otherwise though not terribly inventive or vital.

11/4/12 I watched Frank Capra's The Bitter Tea of General Yen.  An extremely interesting film, one where Capra couches some of his heftiest thoughts and most exquisite aesthetic flourishes into what might appear on the surface as something completely impersonal.  Although less a moving experience for me than one of admiration, I can understand why this one has so many supporters.  

11/11/12 I watched James Whale's The Invisible Man.  Loony and locked in a perpetual hysteria, Whale never shies away from the material.  And the movie is strongest because of Whale's commitment.  Not really my thing though but glad I have now seen it.

8/4/13 I watched Frank Borzage's Man's Castle.  Borzage proves once again he is one of cinema's rare great practitioners of melodrama.  He is very comfortable toiling in the lower class, piling on detail upon detail about how those struggling must feel about money, freedom, and simple, daily survival.  There is something very particular about Borzage's sensibility.  It is unsettling, even creepy while always managing to maintain a connection to real, recognizable situations and emotions.  He was an auteur (one feels a consistent, unique voice from film to film) and this is among the strongest of his w0rks I have seen so far.  

10/6/13 I watched Jean Vigo's Zero for Conduct.  Very possibly the most visually gifted of all the French filmmakers, he was France's Welles, a genius of cinematic language who left the cinema far too early.  Although I am a far bigger fan of his one feature, this film features some remarkable moments like the drawing that comes alive or the famous pillow fight.  Vigo was a surrealist with a playful streak that influenced Carax, Lynch, and so many others.  

7/31/14 I watched D'Abbadie D'Arrast's Topaze.  A film that is at times slightly lethargic from a narrative standpoint more than redeems itself through visual inventiveness and an all-in performance by Barrymore.  I have never seen Pagnol's version so cannot comment on how it stacks up.  D'Arrast proves himself though a very strong director with a keen sense of camera movement and emotive framing.  I was particularly struck by how he slowly pulled back the camera during Topaze's farewell speech to his classroom in the middle of the film.

11/5/17 I watched Lewis Milestone's Hallelujah, I'm a Bum.  Having read that one of my favorite critics, Jonathan Rosenbaum, rated it in his best 100 films of all time, I was extremely curious to see it.  It is exactly the type of film Rosenbaum tends to champion.  It is not stylistically flashy nor even terribly entertaining; however, it tackles complex subject matter and it does so with an intelligence and narrative skill of a very high order.  I may not always agree with Rosenbaum, but it is hard for me to argue with this film deserving attention and great respect.

11/24/17 I watched Raoul Walsh's The Bowery.  I can see why Scorsese would be a fan but a little creaky and not as affecting for me as some of the other Walsh films from the 30s and 40s.  

1/29/18 I watched Clyde Bruckman's The Fatal Glass of Beer.  An early Fields short that has some intermittently funny moments.  

7/14/18 I watched George Cukor's Dinner at Eight.  Most extraordinary is not the drama but the acting and the multitude of characters and social situations we can recognize and have probably experienced.  Not completely sure if it should all be viewed as a critique and/or satire, but it sure seems like it even though Cukor was such a fixture in the world he is depicting.  

7/19/18 I watched George Cukor's Little Women.  FilmStruck celebrates Cukor this week as its featured director, making it as good of a time as any to dig deeper into his work.  He never was a flashy stylist and many of his films seem comfortable taking their time even at the risk of running off some of the audience.  What makes Cukor so special is how deep he goes with his characters.  He trusts their freewheeling spirits, loves them, knowing it is possible both for them to entertain us and allow us into their souls.  As a result, we care an unusual amount about the characters in his films.  Cukor also was a master at restraint.  Just look at how long he withholds things from Hepburn, a practice run for his finest hour a few years later in Holiday.  Less entertaining than Hawks, less visual than Ford, less buoyant than Lubitsch and less clever than Wilder but just as great as them all.  

11/8/18 I watched Howard Hawks' Today We Live.  Not very interesting, with the exception of how weak of a film it is within Hawks' filmography and how much time he gives several action sequences.  

9/18/19 I rewatched Leo McCarey's Duck Soup.  I had forgotten how relentlessly funny much of it is.  It has such a  wonderful child's sense of play and humor and made me, for most of the film, feel like I was on the winning side of some great prank call.  I haven't seen all of The Marx Brothers' films but I would be surprised if they ever topped it.